I was not trying to give John250 ammo to use on Vital and start a war over there, I was merely trying to use statistics of SX season finishes since Dungey and Stewart started racing together to give a perspective of what usually happens in SX. Dungey has been more consistent for the series than Stewart every year - Not a big surprise there. But it might be a surprise to some people that Stewart has never beaten Dungey in Points since the 2 have started racing together for a series. Let's take a look at MX racing now to see how they compare there:
2014 - Dungey 2nd 514 points raced every race, Stewart 9th 226 points - Missed 4 races (8 Motos)
2013 - Dungey 2nd 507 points raced every race, Stewart 5th 289 points - Missed 1 race (2 Motos)
2012 - Dungey 1st 580 points raced every race, Stewart 11th 163 Points - Missed 6 races (12 motos)
2011 - Dungey 2nd 514 points raced every race, Stewart Did not finish top 20 in points
2010 - Dungey 1st 543 points raced every race, Stewart Did not finish top 20 in points
* - Remember that there are 2 motos worth 25 points each in MX, so each race is worth 50 points Maximum and if we give Stewart full points for every race missed, he still never beats Dungey. 2014 he gets to 426 maximum if he wins all 8 motos missed. 2013 - he gets to 339 points maximum if he wins both missed motos. 2012 he gets to 463 points if he wins all 12 missed motos. Every season he is still behind Dungey if we give him the maximum benefit of the doubt for injuries and missed races.
Again, Dungey has been very consistent in lining up and gathering the most points for the season year after year that the 2 have been racing each other. Is he as outright fast on any given day? Probably not, but there is a story as old as the earth between the tortoise and the hare in a race and it seems that Dungey is strapped with the tortoise reputation, while Stewart is the Hare. The tortoise is winning the wars over and over again, simple as that.
The best races I've ever seen were between Stewart and RC when RC was the king of MX and Stewart was trying to dethrone him as the new kid in the big class. Those battles were EPIC and we can safely say who won that war can't we? RC! And I wouldn't say it was because RC was faster then Stewart, I'd say RC was smarter and more methodical about making sure that he won more often than not, as the fastest rider doesn't necessarily win the race.
I just like to see guys battle it out at the front of the pack for wins, those are the most exciting races in my book, and Stewart has always generated excitement when he's going for it - all or nothing attitude. He just hasn't been in the Title hunt for quite some time, which is why I wonder about people saying that if he was racing, he'd be winning the title. I just don't get that mentality.